Well, things have changed in the week or so since our last Veep list, so we’re going to give it a revision — I can see the ads now… “Veep Version 2.0, now with Republicans!”
Let’s narrow it down to 5 for each side, and provide less commentary.
Starting with the Elephants.
5. Sarah Palin – Still an intriguing choice (former Miss, now Gov. of, Alaska, mother of 5, virulently anti-abortion), but I just don’t see it happening.
4. Mike Huckabee – Definitely gets the religious right to the polls, and has executive experience, but his knowledge of economic issues (did you see his tax plan??) is even worse than McCain’s.
3. Rob Portman – Economic savvy, definitely smart, and from Ohio. But he’s a Bush official!!!
2. Mitt Romney – Plusses for almost every category — Michigan, religious conservatives (they seem to have gotten over the whole formerly-pro-choice and currently Mormon thing), executive, business, hair, hair, hair. One big minus, and likely the killer – McCain can’t stand him, from all accounts we’ve seen.
1. Tim Pawlenty – Good grief, I can hardly believe I’ve put him here. The guy is young, and the whole “Sam’s Club, not country club” vision of Republicanism is good for the GOP, but really? He might make Minnesota close, but probably wouldn’t swing it. Some executive experience, and younger, but a rather uninspiring choice.
Off the radar — Gov. Bobby Jindal (honestly, he would have been the best pick — McCain’s and Obama’s respective ages could have deflected the youth question away, and the guy is definitely smart. He’d add diversity to the GOP image, and plays well with the religious right. Dems dodged a bullet); Carly Fiorini (when people stopped to look at this female business executive, they realized, “hey, HP went into the tank under her!”); Charlie Crist (too tan); Joe Lieberman (apparently too liberal, though that is crap)…
And now for the Donkeys.
5. Jack Reed – Newcomer to the list, but the guy is very well-respected, has extensive military experience, great story (father was a school custodian), etc etc. Not as exciting as one might hope, and from New England, but unimpeachable credentials and seems to get along with Obama.
4. Kathleen Sebelius – Moved up, and bumped off Hillary. Obama could bring her in to double up on the “outside Washington” thing. But I still don’t see it happening.
3. Joe Biden – Slips a few spots, as people realize that he often just flies off message. Still my personal choice for Obama.
2. Tim Kaine – Moves up over his recent admission of “serious talks” with the Obama campaign. Again, outside the beltway, and Obama might just try to go “All In” with the change message. I like his approach in Virginia, but apparently many don’t. RealClearPolitics recently posted (you think I give links? ha!) to a piece by Larry Sabato breaking down Kaine’s tenure as governor, and the picture is not terribly flattering. Who knows…
1. Evan Bayh – The smart pick, all things considered. Early Clinton supporter, actually popular enough to perhaps swing Indiana, telegenic, older without being ancient, etc. Do he and Barack get along? If so, I’d pick him up quick.
Off the radar — Sam Nunn (too old, too conservative on a few issues, but expect a cabinet post); Hillary Clinton (she’ll be a speaker at the Convention, all but assuring that she won’t be on the ticket — and let’s face it, the two just don’t get along all that well); Chuck Hagel (change is good, but a unity ticket would stretch the credulity for many liberals — though I like Hagel myself); Chris Dodd (he might get back in the picture, so keep watching…)